Why is this word different from all other words?
What gives the word Nigger such tremendous, terror-inducing power? I mean, it fucking SQUASHES all competitors:
- Kike
- Faggot
- Gook
- even first runner up CUNT can't say jack shit.
Looks like I got a thesis:
The word Nigger's dominance as the universal champion of taboo is directly caused by the ass-beating that is feared by its usage.
(...and not the other way around.)
As for the dominance itself, I don't think I have to convince you that our society holds the N word to be much more taboo than any of those other slurs – but just in case:
Consider the Michael Richards Hubub: Can you imagine a comparable federal calamity occurring if Richards had been shouting kyke? I mean yeah, he would have been chastised, sure, and Simon Wiesenthal would have sent an email to your grandparents and their Bridge partners, and they would have forwarded it with their broken CAPS LOCKs to all their liberal New York grandchildren who would roll their eyes and check it against snopes before squirting out patronizing and self-righteous replies... but can you ever imagine a scene quite like this one occurring, with Michael Richards apologizing on Letterman and looking just about as terrified as a man headed for the electric chair? Think they still would have made him a national villain, with a movement of Jewish leaders launching a stop-the-K-word website and T-shirts and a funeral for the K word?
Nigga please.
So you were right – what you knew instinctively is obviously true: Nigger is way "worse" than all these other words. At first I wasn't sure why, so I asked my mother.
Hey Mom: ma-nish-ta-nig?
It's the fact that people in this country owned slaves and that they institutionally subjugated an entire race - it was a word used to refer to slaves; inhuman merchandise - it was not a slur. Think of Huckleberry Finn - this was reportage - "Did anyone get hurt? Nah, killed a nigger though." This country holds responsibility for that, and that's why Americans place such importance on the N word.
Yeah mom, that's pretty fucked up...But the only 6th generation Americans I know are black! My other best friends are mostly jewish, and they were too busy running from Cossacks to be worried about the slave trade in North America. So I'm not buying that they shoulder the responsibility for slavery because of their skin color... but I do know they're scared to say nigger!
I'm just not buying that the horrors of slavery are what make the N word so taboo. The origins make it a FUCKED UP word, very nasty indeed, but by taboo I'm talking about why people are so afraid to say it. People say VERY VERY fucked up shit all the time, right? So why not this word?
Now call me simple, but to me it's obvious: people are afraid to say nigger because they don't wanna get they asses whooped. That's the only reason nigger beats all those other slurs - you WILL get your ass beat harder and more quickly for using that word than any other.
White people: think of getting caught saying nigger on an A-train packed with scaryblacks. Imagine the fucking violent negro-forearm beat down you'd get? Scream nigger at Jay Street Borough Hall: Your life expectancy will be so fucking short you'll make Sam Metteer look like Michael Phelps.
Now, for contrast, imagine the punishment you'd receive for uttering the respective slurs of the other marginalized groups in their natural habitats:
Women - Go scream CUNT in a shoe store. You'll get screamed at, and worse comes to worse some gigantic kangol-wearing dyke will shove your ass out onto the street. What the fuck ever: compare that shit to getting shivved on the A-train at 155th and St. Nick.
Gays - Go scream FAGGOT at a Gay Pride Parade. Ha! They'll probably just mock you and twirl their pinwheel breast-tassles in your direction. In certain circumstances, like if you were at the fucking Blue Oyster Bar, you could certainly get your ass severely beat (See Eddie Murphy's cannonized "That's some embarrassing shit to get beat up by a faggot" bit from Delirious / Comedian, 1983) but it'd be much rarer. It would take much more specific conditions to really get your ass beat bloody, whereas saying Nigger loudly on pretty much any A-train will immediately cause you to die.
Jews - Go scream KYKE at Zabars or Barney Greengrass. You're gonna get a lot of hairy shouting and huge bobbing Adam's Apples in your face and shit – like the POV scene from Clockwork Orange when all the old muthafuckas are beating my man's ass – but aside from some neck clawmarks or a pot of tzimmes to the nuts, you're walkin outta there unscathed.
Asians - This is the one example that most challenges my thesis, though in the end my thesis escapes as unscathed as an anti-semite shouting "Gimme a quarter pound of kyke" at H&H.
Now, having grown up on Game of Death and Fists of Fury, I know that from a hand-to-hand combat perspective, the chinamen can very much kick the FUCK outta a nigga just using bare hands and those ballet shoes. They can even defeat large men of African descent - Doubters plz review the scene in Enter The Dragon right before the claw battle.
But here's the thing - despite their karate abilities, I just don't get the sense that asians would use this power just because you called one of them a gook. Like the man himself, I get the sense that asians subscribe to a higher moral ethos and obey The Spiderman Credo - whereas niggas on the A train are just waiting for someone to breathe on them wrong so they can rip a caucasian arm out of a socket, tear off the fingers, and sell dem shits in the next car like black truant 13-year-olds slangin' fake batteries to raise money for their imaginary basketball team.
Listen, let's be honest: most people fear black people more than any other race besides sleeper-cell arabs (and that's different). Just consider this observation you've made hundreds of times before, and be fucking honest about it for once:
You see a group of white kids fucking around on the subway, e.g. peeling off MTA stickers, or drawing on a subway map, or cursing loudly, or some shit like that. White bystanders will almost always step to them:
Excuse me kids, can you not deface public property? Cut it out, come on, GROW up, I'm a taxpayer, ok? That's my freakin money, bigshot, okay?
Now consider a bunch of loud-ass ebonics black kids doing the same thing?? Nigga PLEASE; NO ONE will say shit - white people start lookin down and explorin they newspapers so hard you'd think they was Lewis AND Clark.
Even other blacks stay mum. Everyone lets those kids do whatever the fuck they want. Know why? Cause people are scared of scaryblacks! And statistically it's not without foundation: In greater proportion than any other race, blacks are known to have numerous representatives that are big, strong, aggressive, and ready to throw down. (McCarthyistic Politically Correct deniers of this fact, click here to suck my dick)
So the real explanation for the N-word's championship spot in the McCarthyism 2.0 censorship hierarchy is plain as black-and-white: More so than any other race, ethnicity, or subgroup, people are terrified of getting their asses severely beaten by big strong angryblacks. The word nigger is known to piss the SHIT out of potentially violent, often severely racist black people, many of whom may be looking for a fight. Therefore, in a self-fulfilling prophesy, Americans in urban centers wisely avoid the N word like the fucking plagues; All Santa-Claus-ass imaginary ten.

27 comments:
Okay, I disagree here. I AGREE that nigger beats the competition, but lets look at faggot. Again, I agree it wins out in terms of "omg don't say it," but I don't think it TROMPS it. You use the Kramer argument, well lets look at that dude from Gray's Anatomy. Dude got a shit storm. Now, unlike Kramer, he'll work again, but I think we can compare the two.
'Nigger,
I was all ready to go all poly-sci social psych here (as usual) but you know what? You fucking won, 'Nigger. Hand's the fuck down too (no TKO).
There is certain perfection that shouldn't be questioned or altered. So I don't question because I only have much love.
But.... [And I already know the following is not a parallel analogy but indulge me for some relevant discussion sake]
Consider if any of the Michaels (Richards, Tyson, or Jackson for that matter) went this route:
"Heil Hitler!" With our without the little squishy salute (only the British salute is worse).
I argue that "Heil Hitler!" beats "cunt" like paper beats rock. "Heil Hitler!" beats "faggot" like Speed Racer beat Mr. Kadar in the fire race of Kapetopek. "Heil Hitler beats "chink" like I beat it over Sarah H.L. Palin.
Does "Heil Hitler!" beat nigger, 'Nigger? Dunno, but I bet you'd get quite a debate in the Slope.
People mad joke with the words nigger, cunt, and faggot but there's very little room for play with "Heil Hitler!"
Anyway. Perfection today. Your A+, gold star, perfect attendance award, grand champion belt is in the mail.
End note: As a (half-black / non-scary / half-Jew) black I was totally embarrassed that Jerry made Mike Richards apologize on behalf of Seinfeld's residuals. That was weak. Mike didn't need to grovel like that. He shoulda just come on the TeeVee and went, "nigga please."
The Grey's Anatomy thing is a wash. Screaming any one of these five bangers out at a formal workplace will get you either sensitivity trained and/or sacked.
I know this crazy half-Asian navy brat who works for the US Government in DC doing the kind of shit you do with websites or whatever.
One day he was at his desk screaming at his wife on the phone, "I'm sick of this shit...why are all of the kids' teachers niggers?!? I want them to get some real education, etc etc.". He got written up and had to go speak to a govmint therapist or something. He stormed in and yelled at her, "How can I be racist? I fucked seven black girls!". Therapist so nonplussed she said, "Okay." And that was it. Dude still getting paid by us.
Black people are just regarded as scarier/tougher in the US. I remember being younger and hearing about hooligans in factory towns in England, and Scotland, and just assuming they could never be as tough/crazy as black people. Obviously, not the case. The real people you don't want to fuck with are Eastern Europeans/Slavs/Russians/former yugoslavians. Try insulting a Serb or an Albanian or a Russia. Those people are animals.
First, excellent post to kick off the week...
My only challenge plays off your line, "The word nigger is known to piss the SHIT out of potentially violent, often severely racist black people, many of whom may be looking for a fight."
I agree that nothing tops the n-word (although Ty's Heil Hitler comes close), but as far as ethnic fear creating taboos...
I dare you to go to a Muslim country (say Iran, or even a European country, where I'd remind you that yelling the N'word is as illegal as denying the holocaust) and burn a copy of Qur'an or draw a publicly display a drawing of Muhammad or some shit like that.
There's a lot of scarymuslims that are just as "potentially violent" and "often severely racist" (or at least intolerant) out there.
Or here's another one. Go to some place in the bible-belt and start denying Jesus.
Personally I'm WAY more frightened by religious nuts as I am by any minority I might meet on the subway.
All this shit with nigger here is just that, it's here. In the U.S. you are not supposed to say it because scaryblacks will kick your ass. Even moderately safe blacks will fuck you up pretty good. Non threatening blacks(NTB) might fuck you up, but more than likely there will be a scaryblack who heard it too. He/she will be the one to bust your shit on behalf of the NTB (or egg the NTB on until they become somewhat scary, and beat your ass).
I always figured there was some post civil rights rule that says only black people can say it now.
I got my ass kicked by 4 black kids after they heard that I had called them niggers. It was the best thing could of ever happened to my little punk ass.
EM's Delirious is the funniest stand up I have seen. Hands down. His Elvis bit is the best. Anyway, when I used to take the C-train to Kingston-Throop, I feel like it was worse than the A Train. Only thing more uncomfortable than scaryblacks is scaryblacks on a slow running LOCAL TRAIN- even more bored and looking for someone to say one of the trigger words.
@htr
you're so full of shit - you know damn well that on a train packed with scaryblacks and christians, you'd say FUCK JESUS before you'd say nigger.
So don't front.
This scaryblack used to bully me back in grade school until i rammed his nose into a coathook - fuckface.
Fuck man! ... I clicked that 'suck my dick link' and I'm at work... My computer froze up when I tried to close the window so the chicken head went up and down for 2 or three gobbles before I finally got that shit to close. Snap, that was close.
hate is a good topic. see? i told you, boyd rice and shit.
lol.
Grew up in Brooklyn my whole life and I've heard nigger thrown around by peoples of many different ethnic groups. I've always wondered about the unofficial Code of Nigger, which seems to dictate who can and cannot say the word without getting an ass whoopin'. I have one very distinct memory of a Russian guy in my high school greeting his black friend with "What's up, my nigger?" And no ass kickin' ensued. I've also heard it thrown around by Hispanics and South Asians. I would argue that class seems to play a role in the word's usage. The Russians (immigrant white, while not necessarily The Man-white), Hispanics, and South Asians I've seen use the word all appeared to be members of an "urban thug" class with fashion and vernacular tied strongly to the urban black experience. Could it be that immigrant youth (who are not black) have adopted the word as a symbol of their own form of social disenfranchisement? It's always something I've wondered about.
yo fuck JA.
Trend RV
I have to disagree with the idea that the word nigger trumps (or "TROMPS") all the other no-no bad-bad words because of the fear of an ass-beating. As a white guy, I know that the real fear associated with the "n-word" (how fucking lame is that. n-word. What, are we 3 years old?), the real fear is being labeled a racist. Us white folks are totally afraid of being thought of as the racist bigots that we all (you niggers included) are.
@Jerry Sneede
Great comment.
Now, while I wholeheartedly agree with you that McCarthyism 2.0 is the primary motivation for political correctness - i.e. NOBODY wants to be labeled a RACIST...
I would argue that my thesis still holds true; The question was this sir: WHY is it worse to be perceived as a racist who hates blacks than say a racist who hates asians for example?
If, as another commenter suggested, you're on a packed subway with blacks and asians - you gonna tell me you'd yell NIGGER before you'd yell GOOK?
ngaplz; Not exactly Sophie's Choice, is it ;)
I think it might also have something to do with shame or pity, along the lines of what your mom was saying.
Or perhaps it is the contrasting lack of shame for denigrating those other folks out of jealousy or fear.
Your average kike or faggot can afford to buy something to help him forget about his hurt feelings, whereas if you're a nigger, then you're probably soaking in it.
I mean, I know I'm not gonna use the n-word on the A-train, for the reason you mention. But I even feel awkward using it around my white-bread friends and family when I talk up this blog, and none of them would think once about beating me down. I don't think I'd have the same problem bragging about "blogcunt" or "slopeblogger".
Just sayin...
Good arguement. BUT, i would of liked you to of covered why the blacks (fuck PC sry) continually use the word? Is it too bait the white man to use it so they can beat his arse? If the word disappears, it creates a lesser chance a black man can justifiably issue a life threatening beat-down to old whitey.
If its so offensive, why keep the word alive, and its quite obviously WHO are keeping the word alive. But why?
I never hear a Jew, scream "Yo what up, Kyke!" Or a Homo slap hands like "Sup faggott" Let alone a whitey answer his phone like "Whats happenin Cracka!"
It is safe to say most Americans under the age of 40 have been taught by Hollywood to love black folk, this in conjunction with the fact that a huge majority of scary black dudes got sent off to Jail in the 80's - 90's, in conjunction with the fact that poor people have had easy access to abortions further culling potential criminal elements out of society, thusly making 42nd street safe for Disney. All of these elements reduce racial tension in our society, and make it less likely that you'll come across a white person with a genuine bone to pick with black people. Plus, calling people shit like nigger, kike, and fag is obnoxious. While it might feel liberating to say that shit, it's just kind of dumb. What you call p.c. I call common sense.
@anon 6:13
You're the definition of a hypocritical self-righteous PC android.
You express your true feelings - and they are as conservative as Rush Lim's ... but then go defending politeness and superficial courtesy.
"Crack down on the N word - Don't say it, it's RUDE!!! - oh but by the way racism doesn't exist anymore because it was cured by poor blacks having abortions."
shitcock.
Easy there tough guy. You don't think abortion has had any social effects on NYC? Tell me your theory. Why do you think it's o.k. to walk through the the South Bronx in the middle of the night? Why do you think it's cool for you and all your little fucktard friends to move into Bushwick? Let me see you ride your hipster time machine back to 1988 and try that shit. You sure came down hard on me for what you deem to be a politically incorrect thought. What's that about? Go ahead say nigger all you want, just know that you sound like a 4 year old.
I was riding the A-train uptown today and was looking around at all the black people and trying to discern who is a scaryblack. I have a few black people in my life. They vary from not passing the paper bag test to fairly dark, but none of them are scary. They dress conservatively preppy to black fashionista and still none of them are scary.
I look at some guys on the train and they seem scaryblack and they start rattling off spanish and somehow that all changes. Are there scaryhispanics?
Sometimes circumstances force me to talk to other people on the train and usually the black people are friendly which suddenly puts them in the non-scary category, in spite of how they might be dressed. Most people just seem to want to get through their day.
There are people (usually kids) who are mouthing off as they're walking onto the train and I just know not to say ANYTHING to them, much the same way you don't tell black women in theaters to be quiet. And then there are people who have the crazy eye and I don't even look at them.
So how do you differentiate? Who exactly is a scaryblack? I won't be yelling nigger on the train to find out.
its easy. at least in NY - niggas or PRs or DRs will FUCK u UP for being white or Asian and saying nigger.
why is it so taboo? becuz, aside from the holocaust and American Indians (who are so dead no one even insults them anymore) - African slaves in the western hemisphere, America, Brazil, the West Indies - suffered the most. and, like your Arab example, will fuck u up over it.
the more interesting question is how the Ashkenazim, the principal victims of the holocaust - dealt with true HORROR. lets discuss this.
Last semester of college my roommate was from the Bronx and we were paired together because he was nearly expelled for stealing and I because I got caught with a healthy supply of weed. Anyway, his friends were all from places w/ high scaryblack populations like Atlanta, Roxbury, the Bronx, etc. These kids were generally what I would call sylishblacks. (High-top fades, mohawks, Nikeboots, bright-ass hoodies) I'm a white kid from NH, and though we all got along surprisingly well and became friends, the n-word did make a few appearances, all of which scared the shit out of me, even knowing these kids well. About two months in, 7 black kids are in my room and I'm playing bongos while one of them freestyles and the rest of them dance. My freshman year roommate comes into the room obviously drunk, stumbles up to me and yells over the noise, "these niggers are being such niggers." I acted like I couldn't hear him, and he yelled it louder. I stopped playing and got ready, honestly, to help stomp the shit out of him and save my own ass, but nothing happened. Literally, no reaction, just completely ignored him like he never walked in the room. I walked him into the hallway, shut the door, came back, and it was over. Can anyone explain this shit? I mean, these are kids who regularly discussed the concept of "owning" their blackness, researched their african roots, and regularly talked about how I was the first white friend most of them had ever had. Has the word lost its sting with more educated, college-going blacks, or, as I suspect, did that kid get really fucking lucky?
anon 142, your story is near impossible.
either you're lucky or lying or your ex-roomate wasn't as loud as you thought.
Deaf Jam!
Post a Comment